Return to Home Page

Return to Source List

Secondary Sources & Circumstantial Evidence

A secondary source is a record that was created a significant length of time after an event occurred, or by a person who was not present at the event.

Examples might include:

A marriage application which provides the birth dates of the bride and groom would be a secondary source for their birth dates because it was created long after the births, and their actual knowledge of their own births is not reliable. The record would, however, be a primary source for their marriage date. This holds true for the death certificate. It would be a secondary source for the birth date of the deceased person, but a primary source for the date of death, having been recorded, in most instances, by someone in authority at time of the event.

Sometimes a source can only be relied upon as a generality. Baptism or birth dates of known children can provide clues to the year of their parents’ marriage, but at the same time, cannot be considered proof that the marriage actually occurred, or that there were not previously born ‘missing’ children which might radically alter the marriage year estimate. Therefore, children’s birth dates might fit loosely under the heading of secondary source, but, more correctly, would be called circumstantial evidence. Therefore, the children’s data should be seen as support in finding the marriage, but not proof that the event occurred.

After having explained the two terms in the heading, I come to the point. In some cases, I have used the birth of a child to estimate the probable year of the parents' marriage, but this should not be construed to mean that I am stating a fact. Only that the circumstances imply that a marriage occurred.